Blog

The Truth About Used Tires

There’s a lot of misinformation out there when it comes to used tires. Many drivers assume they’re unsafe, worn-out, or unreliable. But the truth is, not all used tires are created equal.

When you buy from a reputable shop like 5 Star Tires & Wheels, you’re getting carefully inspected, tested, and approved tires—often with plenty of life left. These aren’t tires pulled off junkyard cars. They’re quality options that may have been lightly used, returned for cosmetic reasons, or replaced prematurely as part of an upgrade.

We make sure every used tire we sell meets strict safety and performance standards. That means you can drive with confidence, without breaking the bank.

Why Used Tires Make Sense for Everyday Drivers

Whether you’re commuting to work, taking the kids to school, or hitting the road for a weekend trip, your tires matter. But that doesn’t mean you need to drop hundreds of dollars on a new set every time you need a replacement.

Here’s why safe used tires might be the better choice:

1. Affordable Tire Options Without Sacrificing Safety

The biggest advantage? Cost. Used tires typically cost 30–50% less than new ones, making them a solid option for drivers on a budget. But the savings don’t mean you’re sacrificing safety—at least not when you buy from a trusted tire shop near you like 5 Star Tires & Wheels.

Each used tire in our inventory goes through a detailed inspection process to check for:

• Tread depth
  
• Structural integrity
  
• Sidewall condition
  
• Uneven wear or damage
  

If a tire doesn’t pass our safety checklist, it doesn’t go on our shelves—simple as that.

2. Great for Replacements and Matching Sets

Let’s say one of your tires gets damaged beyond repair. You don’t always need to replace all four. In many cases, a quality used tire that matches the tread depth and brand of your remaining tires is the perfect fix—and a far more affordable one.

Buying just one new tire often leads to uneven performance or excessive wear unless it’s identical to the others. Used tires can be a smart solution for keeping your vehicle balanced and aligned, especially when you’re only replacing one or two.

3. Eco-Friendly Tire Solution

Every time you buy a used tire, you’re helping the environment. Tires don’t decompose easily and take up massive space in landfills. By choosing used, you’re contributing to a more sustainable cycle—and giving a second life to tires that still have thousands of safe miles to go.

So if you’re eco-conscious, used tires are a win-win: you save money and reduce your environmental footprint.

Common Concerns (And Why You Don’t Need to Worry)

We get it—used tires still make some drivers nervous. Let’s address some of the most common concerns:

What if the tires are damaged or patched?

At 5 Star Tires & Wheels, our technicians thoroughly inspect every tire for patches, plugs, or hidden defects. If a tire doesn’t meet our strict standards, we simply won’t sell it.

Will they wear out faster than new tires?

Used tires do have less tread than new ones—but that doesn’t mean they’ll wear out instantly. Many of the tires we sell still have 70–90% of their tread life left. And if you’re not driving thousands of miles a month, they could last you for years.

Are used tires safe in bad weather?

Absolutely. We only sell tires that can handle Oklahoma’s unpredictable weather—from scorching summers to icy winters. In fact, many of our used tires are premium brands with solid reputations for wet and dry traction, cornering grip, and braking reliability.

When Used Tires Are a Particularly Smart Choice

There are times when used tires make even more sense, such as:

• Leasing a vehicle: No need to buy brand-new tires for a car you’re giving back in six months.
  
• Selling your vehicle: Want to improve resale value without investing heavily? Quality used tires are the answer.
  
• Unexpected blowouts or repairs: If you’re not ready for a full set, one or two used tires can keep you moving safely until you are.
  
• Seasonal or spare tire needs: Got a set of summer or winter wheels? Used tires make perfect seasonal companions—affordable and temporary.

How to Shop for Quality Used Tires

Here’s what to look for when buying used tires:

• Tread depth: Aim for at least 6/32” or more.
  
• Even wear: Look for smooth, consistent tread wear across the surface.
  
• No sidewall damage: Cracks, bubbles, or dry rot are deal breakers.
  
• DOT codes: These tell you when the tire was manufactured. Most shops avoid anything older than six years.
  
  

Don’t feel like doing all that legwork? Let us do it for you. At 5 Star Tires & Wheels, we’ve already checked off everything on this list. We’ll help you find the perfect fit—whether it’s for your daily driver, family SUV, or lifted truck.